This should be a comment at the end of the post.
Due Date 8/29/2008
Wednesday, August 27, 2008
Am I Wrong or Am I Right? (10 pts)
Here are the class responses to the movie "Great Books: Galileo's Dialogue. Take some time to look at these, and find three points you agree with and three points you disagree with. Explain your rationale.
This should be a comment at the end of the post.
Due Date 8/29/2008
This should be a comment at the end of the post.
Due Date 8/29/2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
22 comments:
first of all i cant get over how good looking the guy in the second picture is. its just distracting
i dont see domeyer in it....
Agree:
1.) The church was wrong and they should have accepted more of his ideas.
2.) All of the pictures seem to agree
3.) I agree with the heliocentric point of view
i agree with the church not accepting the truth. Galileo's ideas caused heresy. the church should have been more open minded. i couldnt find anything i disagreed with either.
1.i agree the church was wrong and they should have been more open minded
2. all the pictures say the same thing
i couldn't find anything to disagree with.
1.I agree that the church should have been more accepting with Galileo.
2.Galileo caused heresy.
3.said the sun is the center of the universe and that the planets revolve around the sun.
1. i agree with the first picture about the church being at fault... they couldn't accept the truth because it was not the popular thing at that time.
2. the guy in the second picture makes me want to puke
3.i agree that Galileo was considered a heretic by the churches because they didn't agree with his ideas.
4. i don't agree with the second picture about the world being the center of the universe
5. i agree with everything else
I agree...
with all of these beautiful pictures
that the church was wrong and should of been more excepting
that Capurnicus said that the sun was the center of the universe
I disagree...
with the one that says earth is the center...which is ours...
and galielo definitely wasn't talking about the titanic
Agreeable:
1. The church is to blame.
2. Galelieo's ideas caused heresy.
3. The church should have been more open-minded.
Disagreeable:
1. Copernicus thought the Earth was the center of the universe.
2. Devon Alber's last name is spelled Alber, not Albert, stressing the fact that there is in fact no "t" at the end of his name...he should be ashamed.
3. The Titanic, as seen in our diagram, was obviously not around during Galileo's time.
Agree
1. I agree with the church was wrong
Disagree
1. I disagree with the second whiteboard cuz capricornius is a heliocentric instead of a geocentric
everything says the same thing...
I can not disagree with an of them because they all have the same idea, and I do think that is was the church's fault because they could have tried to do some of the exp.s to see if Galileo was a lunatic.
Kimberly Meyer
I agree with all the people who though the church was at fault for not excepting Galileo's ideas.
In the second white board i disagree with the 3rd box, the C guy believed in a heliocentric universe not a geocentric one.
I agree with all of the drawings in the 2nd boxes .
I agree all of the people's (but the one mentioned) roles of C.
I AGREE
1. Galelieo's ideas caused heresy.
2. The church is to blame.
3. I agree that the church should have been more open-minded
I DISAGREE
1. Copernicus thought the Earth was the center of the universe.
2. The Titanic that we we're talking about was not around during that time
3. Alber's name is spelled wrong
AGREE:
-All the pictures agree
-All the boards say that the church was at fault
-The boards pretty much agreed with all the answers
DISAGREE:
None
--Julia Wolter
I agree with all the boards that the church was wrong.
And they should have been more open minded. Although, he could have been less arrogant about it.
All the pictures look the same.
And I agree that Galileo was considered a heretic to the church.
all of the white boards say pretty much the same thing
i agree that the church should be more understanding about his ideas
i disagree that copernicus is a geocentric
agree:
1) because of his ideas, galileo was considered a heretic
2) his ideas began the idea of a heliocentric universe
3) the church was at fault because of their one-sided vision
I agree with all the groups in saying that the church was at fault and not Galileo and all the other groups pretty much had the same things so I can't pick out anything I disagree with!
Our white board was the same as the other groups
1) Pictures were mostly the same
2)The church should have listened and been more accepting
3) Agree with heliocentric point of view
I agree that they are all the same and that the church should have been more openminded.
I agree that they are all the same.
I agree
1.) The church was wrong and they should have been more accepting of his ideas.
2.) The heliocentric theory
3.) All the pictures look the same.
Post a Comment